Zuzu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil (Tobacco - Brown)

I'm so glad that I ordered this pencil. It is just what I needed. Ever since Nars discontinued its similar eye pencil (Black Moon), I have searched and searched for a decent eye pencil. Finally, I've found a comparable eye pencil! This is a high quality product and I recommend it to anyone looking for a true eye pencil that looks good, goes on easily, and does not smudge.

Wow! The perfect pencil! I am impressed with the length of wear and even more impressed with no 'raccoon' eyes! Going to order more colors! Goes on easily with no tugging

The wear on my normally oily skin is 3 hours before needing retouching. This pretty eyeliner complements my brown eyes with blue-grey ring and has become my favorite. Slate is similar in tone to the dark grey in natural slate floor tile with blue undertones. It is darker grey than Shiseido "natural black," which despite the name, is a medium-grey.* What's missing from the listing description but printed on my box: sea fennel extract and ascorbyl palmitate *Gabriel makes Zuzu Luxe. I buy their makeup because of high quality and they back their products with stellar customer service. A tube of concealer I bought from them dried out prematurely, so I emailed them about it. They promptly exchanged it with a fresh tube. Orders are packed in biodegradable peanuts and they can recycle the empty tubes of concealer you bought. Excellent product + ethical company = will definitely buy again

This is my favorite new eyeliner. It’s nice and smooth and doesn’t run. I live in south Florida where it’s hot and humid but the eyeliner stays in place.Love the color too. I got leaf and it looks great on olivey/caramel skin.

First off, I have switched all my makeup products to non-toxic, safer products. Zuzu is a great natural brand. I have this eyeliner in Slate (blue-grey), Indigo (cool toned purple) and Iguana (bright green). I have blue-green eyes and all the colors look beautiful and make my eyes pop without looking harsh or overly done up. I've gotten so many compliments on them, especially Iguana, as most people comment they are surprised how beautiful the green eyeliner looks. I've worn these on 90 F degree days all day long with just a setting spray and they've stayed on beautifully. They glide on easily and are just great eyeliners overall.

This eyeliner is great, my eyes are really sensitive and they have not gotten irritated from this eyeliner. I like the color a lot, it is not too light or dark. I love that it’s natural ingredients too.

Con: doesn't stay on! disintegrates and looks uneven and sloppy after an hour. And it irritated my eyes.Junk

I have extreme sensitivity to make-up, in particular eye make-up. I develop terrible allergic reactions to eyeliner and mascara and my eyes run and water. I also develop eczema on my eyelids to regular eye shadow. I have begun using Gabriel products (zuzu is a product of Gabriel) exclusively on my eyes for these reasons. This eyeliner goes on smoothly and generally stays put. It runs a little but can be fixed by setting with some powder. I wish it was a little darker for those times when I want a bolder, evening look, but I really need a liquid liner for that. But for day wear and normal evenings out, this stuff is great.