stila HUGE Extreme Lash Mascara, Intense Black | Volume, Full Length, Curl, Lift, No Clump, Crunch or Smudge | Lightweight, Long-Lasting Buildable Eye Makeup Formula | 0.44 Fl. Oz.

I swear, it seems any Stila product I buy does not dissappoint! This mascara is one of the best I've tried and I have used A LOT of different brands because I could never seem to find one that I love. I can offically say that's changed since this has come into my life! It makes my lashes nice and full with tons of volume that I don't feel the need to HAVE to wear eyeliner, I can go for a more natural look with just this mascara. AND it's price is great for this amazing quality! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE.

Allergies, sensitive eyes make finding a decent mascara a challenge. This mascara is the best product I’ve ever used. Easy to apply. I like the brush, it’s full and has a long wand. The mascara is buildable, and you won’t have to work at it. Great coverage with a couple passes. Ok. So looks great! Now the wait. Best result possible. No stinging, no watery eyes, no running, no smudging, no flaking! Wow! Looked great the whole day. Next test. Mascara is easily removed. I use micellar facial wipes. I’ve tried dozens of products. So many of the organic mascaras are garbage. The product is thin and useless, have a terrible brush, expensive and bring all the flaws that you don’t want in a good mascara. Honestly, just try it. As a lover of big lashes and hampered by allergies I’ve never found a better mascara.

This is the third time I'm buying this. Everyone thinks I'm wearing fake lashes. Makes them long and thick.

The wand is longer than I'm used to, having only formerly used drugstore brands or sample sizes of high-end mascaras. After about a week or so of regular use, though, I got the hang of it and I understand why it's designed that way-- they're trying to prevent the user from having to rest the hand on the side of the face while applying this mascara, thereby potentially rubbing off or smearing already-applied makeup. At first, this meant that I felt like I had less control of the wand, but like I said, it got easier with practice. The brush itself is mostly great. Gets right to the roots, easy to wiggle side to side, and then when I swoop upwards, the volume and lengthening payoff is amazing! My only complaint is that the brush flares out at the very tip, so I usually end up smearing mascara onto my eyelid while trying to get into the smaller lashes at the inner corners of my eyes. Thankfully, it's easy to wash off with a dampened cotton swab, but still... it's one more step and one more thing to throw away. The mascara wears well throughout the day and can withstand minor eye-watering without smearing. It DOES get clumpy really quick during application, and it does flake off and collect under the eyes throughout the day though, so I recommend using only one or two coats while applying it to avoid/ minimize those issues. Overall, it's a pretty good product, and I would buy other products from Stila, based on my satisfaction with this one. It provides the kind of long, voluminous, "wet" lash look that I love. Will keep my eye out for a less clumpy and flaky formula though.

Bought as a gift for my niece and this is literally the ONLY mascara she will use. She lives it that much.

LOVE this mascara! Extra long lashes!

The wand of the mascara was so thick with mascara I couldn't see the brush on the end. Had to scrap it off the brush and finally had to use a tissue to remove all the mascara so that I could use the brush end to apply the mascara. I've ordered this product before and had no issues, so I was surprised to see how messy it was. It was expensive and I expected a better product than what I received. I would return it, but I didn't keep the manufacture's box, because I put it in the recycle which has been picked up.

I am a big fan of Stila's Liquid Eye Liner and shadows, so when I needed a new mascara, I thought I'd try theirs. The reviews were largely excellent, but I find I'm a bit disappointed with this product. First of all, I don't care for the shape of the wand -- it's thicker at the ends and more narrowly curved in the middle. That may suit some, but I rely on the tip of the wand to finely apply my mascara to the lashes at the corners of my eyes. I like the more detailed control of a narrower wand tip and I prefer a more fluid mascara for a more natural look. This mascara is heavy and produces dramatic, very dark lashes -- great for a big night out but that's not what I want for daytime wear. The mascara's texture, as it is being applied, reminds me of school paste and it goes on with a lot of clumps. I also noticed that it smudges and flakes easily after wearing it awhile. I spend more time separating my lashes and trying to remove the clumps than I have ever done with any other brand and I'm having to check in the mirror often during the day to touch up any dark smudges. So, I guess I am going back to my old stand-by, Estee Lauder's Magniscopic.