stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

FABULOUS!!! Stila makes The BEST eyeliner pencil!!! Kudos to Stila!! FINALLY a great eyeliner pencil!! Their pencil dries in about a minute, and does not run and smudge all over to give you raccoon eyes! Great for the water line!!!! Stays there!!! Not hard and dry! Very soft, which makes it very easy to apply. Lasts all day and night with no raccoon eyes!! Goes on smoothly, great texture, etc.. Thank you, thank you, thank you, Stilla!!! It took me a long time to finally find the best pencil out there!! I have ordered Urban Decay, Maybelline Unstoppable, Tatoo Studio, Make Up Forever, Benefit Bad Gal Bang, Elf, Chanel, Estee Lauder, and more. They all smudged causing raccoon eyes, didn’t work for the waterline without smudging under the eyes! They are all in the garbage! Thank you Stilla for making a terrific product and being 100% honest about it!!

Really like this eye liner! Goes on so smoothly on my mature lids and stays put. I can easily tight line my lids and it stays in place. Doesn’t run either as some other lines do. It is not dry, or cakey. Does not have self sharpener so I have to take a tissue and gently re-create a slender point for tight lining. That is a bit of a negative. I think this liner is a quality product and will order another color

I am so happy to have found this pencil in gilded green. I have amber eyes and this color is perfect for them. A long time ago I had an eyeliner pencil very similar to this but the brand stopped making it. I kind of gave up on ever finding it again but came across this by sheer luck. It’s a gorgeous vintage looking green with tiny sparkles. It looks super pretty on the bottom waterline. I’ve used lots of Stila eyeliner pencils and they’ve all been great. Love the brand and quality. Lasts all day on me, doesn’t smudge unless you intentionally smudge it for a smoky look and the colors have all been really nice. The pencil is kind of creamy but not too soft. Sharpens well and there’s not a lot of waste from having to sharpen it too frequently. The wood sharpens well too without splinting or having any sharp edges. They do not irritate my sensitive eyes or dry out my skin. I am an older makeup girlie (57) and these still look good on me even with the sparkles. So if you’re older I recommend you go for it. It’s super flattering and easy to use.

This is a pretty decent eyeliner pencil (and I've tried OH so many!). It glides on so smoothly and easily (especially when it is new). It doesn't smudge, smear, or give raccoon eyes. It lasts all day and is easy to remove with eye makeup remover. The pencil is a little fat (can't be sharpened), and after about a week it seems to become a bit dryer so it doesn't glide on quite as smoothly as when it is new. I like that it comes in brown since black is too harsh for me. I will continue to buy it.

I really like this product - quality is much better than expected! It glides on very smoothly (not dry like pencil) and I worried it would stay moist and smudge around. Instead, it stays put very nicely! I got the purple color and it's a subtle enhancement for my green eyes.

Been using this for years. When you crunch the numbers this costs $24 and lasts about 30 days. That's 80 cents a day or 40 cents an eye per day for A LINE that's 1/16" thick and about 1/2" long. There are much better eyeliners for a fraction of the cost.

The liner itself does not last long at all! It stays on all day, but I am already almost out of it and I’ve only had it a little over a month.

One of my absolute favorite eyeliners! Really need to check out the other colors but it goes on really smoothly and lasts all day, as long as you aren't constantly rubbing your eyes. 10/10 would purchase again!

Great colour and lovely to apply.

Too hard to wash off

I originally received this eyeliner in a bag of cosmetics bought from a well known store. Although this is an eyeliner i use it on my eyebrows & because its waterproof it stays put for longer than any eyebrow pencil i have tried. Because it is described as gel it simply glides on making it easy to achieve the desired shape. Love the colour too. Bit on the pricey side but worth it.

This is an awesome eye liner. It stayed on all day. It did smudge later but I was rubbing it.

This lasted all day and night without running or smudging and is my favourite product now.