
Desertcart purchases this item on your behalf and handles shipping, customs, and support to Tunisia.
desertcart.com: King and Emperor: A New Life of Charlemagne: 9780520314207: Nelson, Janet L.: Books Review: Excellent overview of 8th century Europe - This is quite simply an excellent book by an author/scholar whose research is impeccable. I was hooked after the thirty page introduction which serves not only as an introduction to Charles and his time, but as a primer on how to present history without resorting to historical fiction. It requires legwork, and detective work and then connecting the dots provided by the disparate findings. Charlemagne is the focal point, of course, but 8th and 9th century Europe are equally important. The author lets the research speak for itself: she explains which contemporaneous documents can be trusted and which are best taken with a grain of salt. All-in-all, a definitive treatment by an author who is a true expert on the subject. Review: Well-researched biography - This was a challenging read, but I made it all the way through. Charlemagne’s age was not one rich in literature or historical writing and the historian has no choice but to patch together a biographical narrative from whatever legal documents and various funerary inscriptions exist and survive. On this basis, a good chronology of Charlemagne’s life and empire emerges, but only a shadowy image of the man himself. The author’s emphasis is very much on documenting these sources and how the biographical puzzle is put together. As a biography this makes for a rather disjointed reading experience. But as historiography it is still quite interesting. In the end a picture of the man does emerge. But the focus is more on the man than his wider world. To fully understand the time and world of Charlemagne, the reader needs to regard this book as only one building block, to be complemented by others focusing more broadly on early medieval society, economy, religious life and ideas, of the Franks as well as those peoples they came in contact with.
| Best Sellers Rank | #82,771 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books ) #27 in Ancient Rome Biographies #69 in French History (Books) #138 in Royalty Biographies |
| Customer Reviews | 4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars (327) |
| Dimensions | 6 x 2.1 x 9 inches |
| Edition | First Edition |
| ISBN-10 | 0520314204 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-0520314207 |
| Item Weight | 2.36 pounds |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 704 pages |
| Publication date | September 17, 2019 |
| Publisher | University of California Press |
S**Y
Excellent overview of 8th century Europe
This is quite simply an excellent book by an author/scholar whose research is impeccable. I was hooked after the thirty page introduction which serves not only as an introduction to Charles and his time, but as a primer on how to present history without resorting to historical fiction. It requires legwork, and detective work and then connecting the dots provided by the disparate findings. Charlemagne is the focal point, of course, but 8th and 9th century Europe are equally important. The author lets the research speak for itself: she explains which contemporaneous documents can be trusted and which are best taken with a grain of salt. All-in-all, a definitive treatment by an author who is a true expert on the subject.
K**N
Well-researched biography
This was a challenging read, but I made it all the way through. Charlemagne’s age was not one rich in literature or historical writing and the historian has no choice but to patch together a biographical narrative from whatever legal documents and various funerary inscriptions exist and survive. On this basis, a good chronology of Charlemagne’s life and empire emerges, but only a shadowy image of the man himself. The author’s emphasis is very much on documenting these sources and how the biographical puzzle is put together. As a biography this makes for a rather disjointed reading experience. But as historiography it is still quite interesting. In the end a picture of the man does emerge. But the focus is more on the man than his wider world. To fully understand the time and world of Charlemagne, the reader needs to regard this book as only one building block, to be complemented by others focusing more broadly on early medieval society, economy, religious life and ideas, of the Franks as well as those peoples they came in contact with.
A**R
A scholarly page turner
Written by a doyenne in the field, this biography gets off to a very bad start with a chapter on pre-Charlemagne family history that makes your head spin with dozens of Frankish names being fired at the reader. I nearly gave up. Fortunately, when we get to Pippin, Charles's father, things calm down and the book becomes utterly absorbing. Drawing on the surprisingly large number of Carolingian documents still available and best specialised studies, the author constructs a masterly narrative with welcome shafts of humour and extraordinary insight. The writing is never sentimental and there is no hint of hero-worship; but I nonetheless felt quite sad when the Emperor died.
N**Y
Arguably an authority of the life Charlemagne
Very engaging. Discussed a period, events, and marble man like Charlemagne. The erudite author is exemplar.
K**K
A tough slog.
This is a dry-as-dust analysis of documents issued by Charlemagne. It is not a biography such as we expect from an historian. It is not the author's fault. Ninth-century monks, the usual authors of these documents, did not have the same historical sense we take for granted. "Biography," so far as it existed, was hagiography. The documents themselves are charters issued from Charles' court and deal with mundane matters such as which abby is entitled to whatever vinyard. Charles was an early medieval warlord in the crude and cruel world of the post-Roman centuries. He is remarkable because he especially valued learning and something like the rule of law. Mostly, though, he fought and conquered - for a king's business consisted of just that. This is not a "life and times" biography. It is about Charles but mostly about the documents from his reign. These are fascinating to medieval historians -- which most of us are not. Only a shadowy picture of Charles emerges from the four-hundred pages of the book. He was powerful, somewhat learned, a patron of learning, a law-giver in the Frankish bandit-chief mode and he briefly unified most of what became Europe and then everything, once again, went to hell. Other scholars speak of the Carolignian Renaissance, an effloresence of scholarship, art and political sophistication. This biography does not go there. it is about documents. Really boring ones.
M**R
Thorough
This book is a very thorough and detailed description of Charlemagne’s life. Highly recommended.
S**C
Very scholastic
This is an excellent book but it does require a great deal of patience with tiny details that block any real narrative from emerging. If you are a medievalist who is deeply into the 8th and early 9th centuries this is likely the best biography of Charlemagne that will be written for a while. But it is not easy reading and a little more narrative would have helped.
S**S
The times he lived in
Extremely thorough and well written
S**S
Compehensive history with well defined sources
P**Y
This book is a very detailed and thoroughly referenced book about Charlemagne’s life. However, unless you’re an expert in this field, I would not recommend purchasing this book. It is an extremely slow read with many details that are unnecessary. I am not a stranger to boring history books, but I had a difficult time with this book. The author spends the majority of time discussing where the information came from which is important but makes for a terrible read. I’m sure tremendous work went into making this book, but it certainly is not made for people who just want to learn about Charlemagne and the Carolingian Empire.
A**E
Sheds light on the birth of modern Europe, 1200 years before hand? Having never heard the history, its such a compelling tale. Every bit as compelling as the biography of Hamilton, when is the musical, rap album or Netflix series due?
X**E
Janet Nelson, one of the leading authorities on the Carolingian period, had updated Charlemagne’s biography to modern scholarship. Sure, there is no small amount of ink spent on this most known monarch of the Middle Ages. But recent scholarship has certainly gained some new insights that justify a new biography. However, it also is not more than that. As a medievalist myself, I expected an innovative synthesis on the person and government of Charlemagne. After all, it is under his rule that first forms of knighthood emerged, but also were the just question can be posed to what extent it was militarily functional. Or what about the views in courtly culture tying the aristocracy more profoundly to the royal authority. The chronological approach forgoes a methodological approach of such contemporary historiographical perspectives. Nonetheless, it will benefit a larger audience desiring a more traditional narrative of one of the most fascinating people of the medieval times.
F**M
Il libro mi è piaciuto molto. Non è esattamente divulgativo, anzi è quasi accademico. Ci sono continui riferimenti ai documenti storici sui quali si basa la conoscenza del personaggio e del periodo. Fa capire, tra le tante cose, la difficoltà degli storici nel ricostruire avvenimenti di periodi tanto lontani da noi. In alcuni punti la lettura è faticosa, per il tentativo di fare collegamenti fra le varie fontie avvenimenti che si incrociano. Le 4 stelle sono però per l'inadeguatezza delle mappe, poche e tutte assieme all'inizio del volume, e per la mancanza di schemi o tavole di sintesi.
Trustpilot
1 week ago
2 weeks ago