MILK BAR Cookie Variety Pack, Chocolate Chip and Sugar Cookies with Marshmallows and Compost, Soft Baked, 3 pack

I love these cookies!! They’re different (in size, texture, flavor) than the cookies you buy at Milk Bar + I find them to be the perfect at home / on the go treat! The size is perfect for when I want a little treat vs. indulging in a big cookie from MB (there are certainly times for that too...) It makes sweet snacking at home so much more fun (and tasty) than regular store bought cookies + while the confetti are my favorite, I always buy the 3 pack just to have options. :) The cartons are also so fun + festive (see photo) that I keep them on hand to give to friends to spread the love (I mean, who wouldn’t want to be greeted with a fun box of cookies?!) Highly recommend ordering these + making your days a little more fun (+ a little more sweet!)

First of all, these are very good cookies. They are well made, have clever flavors, and are packaged well. However, they are not the same size or quality as the Milk Bar cookies you get if you order direct from Milk Bar. I assume they have a completely different production model for these retail cookies. These are similar to Keebler chewy cookies from any grocery store. They really shouldn’t come with the premium Milk Bar price tag because they are not premium cookies.

Don’t even buy these. Way overpriced. I first discovered milk bar on the Netflix special ,chefs table or something like that. Man, it looked SO GOOD. And even though we have a location here, and it was against my better judgment to buy packaged cookies over the real thing, I wanted to finally give milk bar a try. As a first impression, these cookies would lose them business, I swear. These cookies SUCK. Just pitiful. They are small, taste and feel just as processed as any other cookie you can buy on a store shelf, AND they are the exact same size, as the store bought cookies too (see above left) Major disappointment, especially considering they were 20 bucks. As you can see by the phot on the right, for every package of cookies, (two in a pack) you get ONE cookie with a decent amount of toppings and one sad sad wanna be cookie to pair with it. I wish I could get my money back. I’m sure the actual milk bar is perfectly fine in person, but I would stop selling these stupid little cookies because they make me not even want to take the trip over to the real establishment, at risk of being disappointed twice.

Really enjoyed this variety pack! In reading reviews from people who have tried both, the bakery cookies are larger and have a different texture from these smaller cookies (2 smaller cookies, perfectly packaged for snacking). If you're a sweet and savory fan, you'll love the Compost Cookies, made from a delightful combo of pretzels, potato chips, coffee, oats, graham crackers, chocolate chips, and butterscotch. I thought I was going to like the Compost Cookies the most because I love mixing sweet with savory, but Milk Bar's twist on the classic chocolate cookie (by adding cornflakes! and marshmallows!) resulted in a magical chewy texture interspersed with tiny bits of crunch that won my tastebuds over. Last but not least, if you have a sweet tooth, you might enjoy Milk Bar's Confetti Cookie - a buttery, sweet vanilla experience brightened up by colorful confetti sprinkles!

The confetti cookies taste like vanilla ice cream and look even cuter! Rainbow sprinkles add a pretty pop of color for anyone interested in aesthetics. Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow cookies are TO LIVE FOR! These were probably my favorite flavor as the cornflakes add a nice crunch, while the marshmallows really up the game of your average chocolate chip cookie. Pro Tip: warm cookies in the toaster oven and then let them sit for a minute or so (searing sugar needs to cool) Although I thought the compost cookies would knock my socks off, they feel short... The caramel chips tasted artificial. Hate to say it, as I love the other two! Also, the amount of plastic packaging is overwhelming. Every set of cookies are individually wrapped! They stay fresh for longer but, let's be honest, who leaves cookies for that long after opening a box? lol Follow me @FoodieSkye for more flavor profiles!

These cookies are not good and although I have never had any products from a Milk Bar location I am pretty sure their products do not take like any store bought cookie. These cookies all taste the same and taste extremely like manufactured, preservative filled cookies. It was a warm day when these were delivered and the chocolate was melted so I put all the cookies in the fridge and they all become stuck to each other in the packages. The cookies all have a weird unnatural texture too and you can’t really distinguish the different ingredients/add ins in the Compost and Cornmeal cookies. I am a huge fan of Milk Bar and Christina Tosi and this is not the quality of product I believe truly represents them.

These cookies are adorable and delicious. The packaging is perfect—each pack is a colorful milk carton, fitting for the Milk Bar brand! Each carton comes with 4 two-packs of cookies. They're perfect to take on the go, for work, school, college, or travel! They open super easily too. The cookies are delicious and flavorful! I really enjoyed confetti, as it had more sweetness and flavor (and I'm not usually a confetti cookie person). They're thin and soft, pretty close to the feel of fresh cookies! I've unfortunately never had Milk Bar cookies in NYC, so I can't compare. But I did enjoy these! They do run out fast, though, and 4 packs in each box is not a ton. They're a little pricey, but not terribly. So enjoy them and savor them! I absolutely recommend!

I honestly bought this because I needed to hit $35 for overnight delivery but oh my god. The confetti cookies smell like cake, the smores cookies are phenomenal, and the compost cookies are like chocolate chip cookies but razzle dazzled. They have the soft texture of a chewy chips ahoy and the flavors are fantastic—sweet but not overly so. I've never had anything from Milk Bar so I assumed it would be overhyped and overpriced, and while it's no cheap box of chips ahoy, it's definitely good. I'm on a budget so idk if I would buy again, but having packs of semi-affordable swanky cookies to share with my friends during our D&D games was pretty cool.