Artificial Grass Puppy Pee Pad for Dogs and Small Pets - 20x25 Reusable 3-Layer Training Potty Pad with Tray - Dog Housebreaking Supplies by PETMAKER, Medium

Very good quality product, as expected

Excellent product that works well for my toy poodle

Picture is accurate. Bought 2 to compare - this one was cheaper. The quality is fine but the other one has a much deeper tray to collect the liquid with a small tray that is removeable. This is not as user friendly - get what you pay for but I'd pay the extra next time. Probably better for smaller breeds

cheap plastic, the grass looks very bad and is already losing pieces. My dog doesn’t want go close because of the strong smell of plastic

My dog took a while to get used to it but it is really effective

Good quality and

It didn't work with my dog . It gives a nasty smell so fast and it doesn't absorb which makes the normal pads better

It did the job, my dog is using it when it is so hot to go outside for a walk

In response to frustrated reviewers and to those considering buying this… (I’m not paid, I’m a regular customer like you). I know this is a long review, sorry, but these tips are very helpful based on my own experience. Thank you to other reviewers for helping me learn what and what not to do. This “grass” is NOT absorbent, look at the pictures in the ad. I intentionally wanted permeable, (after reading the reviews), so that I can use potty pads underneath for the ease of cleaning. Yeah I gotta buy the pads regularly, the cost of convenience, but I don’t mind cuz it’s easier than what other reviewers have stated they’ve gone through. Gotta pick my battles. I live in a 3 story apartment, so when I’m not feeling well or just not wanting to hike the stairs, I’ll have the dogs potty on the “grass” (and pads) on my patio. I replace the pads often and pick up the poo right away, (of course the poo will stick if not picked up right away. LOL ). Other reviewers have complained that their dogs won’t use this “grass” cuz their dogs “aren’t stupid and can’t be fooled.” Goodness, that’s a given. This “grass” IS a different feel, it IS fake, it DOES LOOK fake, and, yes, your dog WILL respond to it differently than they do to natural grass. This stuff is artificial… It takes patient training and time to TEACH your dog to use it. TRAINING: What I do to train… when I know my dog’s gotta go, I’ll stay nearby, encouraging it to WILLINGLY, not forcingingly, merely step on the “grass” by luring with treats and praise. I initially don’t expect my dog to stay on it long, much less potty on it. I follow up with praise and treats every time they do step on it. I’ll repeat this every time they gotta potty until the dog learns it pleases me to be on it. I won’t take them to natural grass, leaving them no choice but to eventually potty on the “grass.” If I have to, cuz the dog won’t potty on it, I’ll leave the potty area with the dog to mentally “reset” myself and the dog for a few minutes, then try again, repeating until successful. (POSITIVE ASSOCIATION is imperative)! Initially, my dog would potty next to it instead of on it, so I would KINDLY pick him up mid stream and put him on the “grass” while constantly praising him as he’s going. (They can’t stop once they start, so this works LOL). When he DOES go potty on it, even if I have to place him on it, I will give EXCESS praise as he’s going and then LOTS of treats after he’s finished. (I buy freeze-dried treats - most dogs cannot refuse liver! They make beef liver, chicken liver, pork liver, salmon, beef liver with pumpkin, etc. Freeze-dried is WAY healthier, it’s only one ingredient, so it does not upset my dog’s sensitive tummy - no stinky farts LOL. You cannot find these awesome treats at Walmart, you gotta go to a pet store, but it’s so worth it! I take the time to use scissors to break them into bit-size pieces - it’s one of my relaxing mindfulness activities). Anyway, NEVER EVER get mad or frustrated with your dog or it’ll associate being in trouble with being on the “grass” and then you’ll never have success! Repeat this process every time you want them to potty on the “grass.” Once they figure out what you want, it’ll eventually feel more “normal” to your dog. Even though my dogs have figured it out after a couple weeks, I still praise and treat every time cuz it’s NOT real grass, it’s not natural for them to potty on it. My dogs are still getting used to it, but they’re starting to use it more readily. This takes time! Be patient with them! Remember, dogs only wanna please you, so give them time to figure out what you want from them, then they’ll be more willing to do what you want. This applies to everything you want them to do - sit, stay, etc. (This even applies to children). After only a couple times of urinating on the “grass,” I’ll replace the pads, but I keep it outside. If I used this thing inside my home, I’d replace the pads every time cuz I HATE the smell of urine! Using pads replaces the work of cleaning the entire setup - that’s just too much work and it’s gross! I rarely have to clean/rinse the “grass” itself cuz it’s permeable and the pads take the brunt. My dogs won’t use the “grass” if the pads underneath are overused - I wouldn’t either if I had to pee on this thing. (Yes, the “grass” is very thin, it’s permeable)! I’ve not had trouble with the “grass” shedding or from an initial/brand new odor, not from this brand anyway. I have two different sizes cuz I had to figure out the right size. My boys are both 17 lbs, I will be buying another large size to give them more space. For large dogs, I recommend using 2-3 large “grass” setups placed next to each other like mine are - refer to my pix. Remember to keep the included plastic bottom under the pads. In my picks, I have one medium and one large setup. I keep a tightly closed trash bag inside a lidded trash can to manage the odor. I replace the trash bag when necessary. I use regular poo bags to pick up the poo. Again, I’m sorry for this long review, but I find it necessary to help you understand how to use this product properly. I spent a lot of time writing this review, BTW, to make sure it’s right. I hope this helps. Enjoy the convenience.

Decent quality, arrived on time, all parts as listed. Happy with purchase

So long story short... I had a Yorkie who lov d to be almost 18 and was actually still super spunky but her kidneys shut down. I just so happened to find a puppy that was conceived the same week I had to say goodbye. She is now 8 months old and potty training has been a struggle. She is smart and stubborn. We have been training her to go both on this grass potty pad and the grass outside and it is definitely helping. Her crate ( a.k.a. the puppy condo) stays clean now. Now we are just working on getting her to go in there and use it when she's running free while we are home. The reason though, I think finding this was a blessing is because because I'm older and wiser this go around and realize that a dog shouldn't have to hold their bladder as long as my previous little girl did. She was so good and never had accidents until she couldn't help it anymore. I was 16 years old and none the wiser about being away for too long. Now I have the comfort in knowing that my new pup will be able to do her thing whenever sh needs to once we get this perfected.

I am so happy with this purchase. I have a little Chihuahua Bobbi I was having a hard time potty training. I got this put a doggie pad beneath the grass and it was all set. At first she looked at it and didn't really like it. She went on a pad so I put her poop on the grass. After that she went on it. It took her about three days to get used to it now she either goes outside or on the pad. It has been a lifesaver and no accidents in the house. You have to clean it regularly so they will continue to use it and I wash off the whole thing once per week. It is durable, does not smell, and was large enough for my dog. I have recommended it to my friends and family. It is an awesome product.

These work great when trying to get your puppies potty-trained. But they are hard to clean. You will never get the smell out completely. I used a urine cleaner, let it sit for an hour, and then spray them out outside with the water hose. I hang them on the rails of the front porch to let them dry. It’s also best put puppy pad underneath them on a black tray (like the ones in kennels). When the puppies get used to going on these pads, I move the pads closer to the door to get then used to going outside .