4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara, Lengthening and Thick, Long Lasting, Waterproof & Smudge-Proof, Hypoallergenic Formula 2 Pack Black

Just buy it. I don't do false lashes, so I have been looking for a mascara that doesn't smudge or clump, etc... After the one I found stop being sold, the search for a replacement has been terrible until now. This one does what it is supposed to do. You can do a natural look or if you apply multiple coats of course you will get a little more dramatic (not very dramatic). You probably will not get the total false lash look that is over the top, but I don't need that. This one will give you just what you need. It dries quickly, no clumping, no raccoon eyes and no smudging. It definitely washes off very easily, with water, even though it is waterproof (I know that sounds crazy). You just have to try it. You get two tubes, can't beat that. I will be purchasing more before this one disappears like the last one I found. If you are looking for a good everyday, good quality mascara, for all ages. This is the G.O.A.T!! Of recent!! Just try it!!

Love this mascara makes my lashes longer and thicker

The mascara does seem to lengthen my eyelashes, doesnt flake and stays on all day. When I purchased it, I thought it included the duo kit that includes the mascara and the separate fibers in the 2nd tube. My fault for not reading more closely; I wouldve found out that it is a 2-pack of standard mascara. While this does lengthen my lashes, I get better results with the fibers in the separate tube. I will keep this on-hand for my purse or travel but will be looking to purchase the duo fibers mascara

I love this product makes your eyelashes long no flaking!!

This product is fantastic! It really does lengthen the lashes and makes them look fuller without being clumpy. I highly recommend this product.

This mascara did not build and lengthen my sparse lashes as much as I had hoped and it did not perform as well as the last brand I purchased. It also left my eyes itchy for several days. It also wasn't as waterproof as I thought it would be but it was easy to remove. The brush is thick and easy to use, the container is nice, and the mascara was wet enough to apply easily. There were some long strands that kept coming out of the bottle when I dipped the wand. They include a nice drawstring bag for each tube for storage/toting. However, this mascara just did not perform as well as I expected and left me with itchy eyes so I would not purchase this brand again.

Purchased in April. Opened one tube right away to try. It was DRY so didnt come out at all! Just went to open 2nd one thinking the first one was a lemon. Same thing! Too late to return so I am OUT the money! Very disappointed! Will never buy again!

Short version: Buy it. You won't regret it. (Unless you want waterproof, which this is not, but it's still a great value.) Long version: Definitely makes my eyelashes look fuller & longer. Beats every drugstore mascara I've tried. Not sure how it compares to higher-end ones, I don't really buy those. The one I got seems water resistant, but not waterproof. If my eyes get watery, it doesn't smear, but if I splash my face w/water, it will. I don't mind, I wasn't looking for a waterproof mascara anyways. If you are, this probably isn't the one you want. It's hard to remove w/water & soap. I use makeup remover wipes, it removes easily. The best part for me: I don't mess up as much using this mascara. If I accidentally blink before it dries it doesn't get all over my face. Not sure how this is even possible: if I accidentally tap the brush slightly on my face, there's little to no transfer (to a point, obviously) and when there is, I can usually wipe it off quickly without having to redo whatever makeup it landed on top of. Yes I can be clumsy, but this stuff helps make that less obvious. It can get clumpy if I curl my eyelashes again after applying. With a very light first layer, after it dries, it doesn't get clumpy if I curl once more. After that I apply a couple more times. Looks better than any other way I've tried, and better than any other mascara I've tried. I will be ordering more as soon as possible. This is my new regular.