Organic Lip Liner Pencil, Long Lasting Lip Makeup, Sharpenable, Sugarplum

Love this color. Happy to find an organic product that I like as much as my old toxic one. The first time I ordered, I loved it. The second order came, and it is a white "pencil" with a bottom that twists. I discovered that this is ALSO a PENCIL that you SHARPEN. The bottom comes off and is just a cover. I was near to returning till I saw someone else's review telling me the same.

This just does not have much pigmentation. I have to line my lips like 10 times to get any pigment. I prefer lip products I can apply really fast. Maybe the product needs to warm up first or something, idk. It just doesn't transfer onto your lips easily. The clean ingredients drew me in, but I probably wouldn't buy this again just due to the lack of pigment. Once I get it on though, it looks very natural and is a beautiful pink color that perfectly matches my lips. You can't tell I'm wearing lipliner. I use the Revlon sharpener to sharpen it and that worked great. Don't try to use some cheapo office sharpener with makeup pencils.

I would like to say the packaging was amazing the getting two complementary samples isn’t something that most people do anymore ! The coffee scrub and a moisturizer. Both are fantastic again being organic it feels good to put some thing on your skin that’s 100% natural. I love that the pencil, for the lip liner came with its own sharpener, And the beautiful thank you note is the icing on the cake

I missed some facts in purchase; this is not a pencil you can sharpen! When I first received and tried this on, the color was perfect and I liked it was organic, however it wore down quickly and there was not enough core in the tractable tube to last even two weeks. If you want something to last a normal life worth your while, wait until they change their unethical manufacturing.

This lipliner does not have much pigment to it, and I have to apply very heavily to see it at all. In addition, the product is not a wooden pencil but is made of some kind of plastic. I was able to sharpen the plastic, but the picture is misleading and if you are thinking of buying this product because it is eco friendly, I would recommend finding something else.

I have been slowly trying to replace all of my beauty products with organic and sustainable items. This lip liner is amazing! It glides on easy and is the perfect color. I would definitely purchase again! It even comes with a little sharpener.

I originally purchased one for my daughter, but she said so many good things about it that I had to get one for myself, as well! This lip liner lasts! I love that about it! I use it a lip liner, and as eye shadow! It is just amazing!!

Nice color pencil. It's casing resembles plastic and I wasn't sure if it would even sharpen with a sharpener. I tested it just a little on the white casing, and it does work in a sharpener, but the color inside smooshes when I sharpen it. 4 stars because I think it should just be a wind up to preserve the expensive product.