it Cosmetics No-tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner (Black)

This is the ONLY gel eyeliner that does what it says it does. The colors look great and they last all day, it stays on, is totally waterproof, cry proof and is easy to apply. Honestly, my eyes tear A LOT. I have dry eye and for some strange reason, it makes them tear a lot. I know, weird. So, I have to use drops and stuff, and this wonderful product stays put, and looks great all day. I used to use another eyeliner, which I liked how it would go on and look, but by the end of the day it was gone. If I was at a party and laughed with my eyes involved (you know, a BIG laugh till you cry one), I would end up looking like a racoon at best and Alice Cooper at worst. Very embarrassing. My eyelashes are sparse, so I don't always wear mascara. I KNOW that it wasn't the mascara that was running. It was my old eyeliner.I highly recommend the IT line of gel eyeliners. This eyeliner is the real deal - it stays on and doesn't run.

The photo is my liner after a six-hour shift on an 85-degree day. :) I use a different liner for the wing.Reviewers that say this eyeliner does not stay on must not be doing anything besides applying this straight to their lids. People ask me all the time how my waterline stays looking great all day, and here is the life-changing secret:If you have very little time and/or want no extra fuss like I do sometimes just skip steps 4 and 5. You'll still get better results than the liner alone!1. Take a Q-tip and carefully, gently dab across your waterline. This gives the eyeliner something to stick on!2. Apply eyeshadow primer. (Urban Decay's Eyeshadow primer potion works wonders, get the travel size!)3. Apply your eyeliner as usual.4. Set your liner with a light, loose powder.5. Seal everything in with a light misting of Setting spray (Highly recommend Urban Decay's All Nighter Setting Spray)I won't use any other liner for my waterline and lash line- it goes on like butter, and stays on like glue.

It's easy to break off the tip of the liner when sharpening and so I don't sharpen as often as I'd like. I also have broken several of the ends of the liner pencil where the built in-sharpener is located. But the liner glides on easily and stays on for the day. I like this liner better than any other I've tried and I'm in my early 50's. And it is nice to have the built in sharpener but remember to be careful when sharpening!

While the color is darker than I expected - it is more black to me with not really much brown to it, I still love it. It glides on easily, and will stay on for my whole 9 hour work day. If I am going out at night I usually do touch it up, but it does stay put as far as no smearing (I do use a eye primer so I don't know if that makes a difference). I am not crazy about the sharpener - it doesn't really give you that good pointed tip like when it was new, so after the initial use, the tip gets dull and the line gets thicker. It is one of the better no tug eyeliners that I have tried.

I love this liner because it’s so smooth and easy to put on is definitely no tugging however if you happen to leave the cover off even just for one day it dries up the stick it’s also hard to use the self enclosed sharpener on the end of the pencil but otherwise I’d like this product

This is a great eyeliner. I didn't realize that other eyeliners tugged (pulled at your skin or got caught on eyelashes) until I used this. The application is very smooth, it goes on dark the first time, and it lasts a long time. Very good buy.

This is my “go-to” eye liner and so hard to find anymore in black-brown. They only shipped me one - but sent the other 2 right away after notifying them.Stays on aaallll day and easy to apply.

I ordered 2 and the first one i used was fine. When I used up that one and started using the second one, I was very disappointed because this one was very dried out, so I couldn't even get it to apply to my eyelids without the product breaking off. Unfortunately, since I didn't open this one until after the return window closed, I am stuck with a product that I can't use.

Never use any other eye liner ,this one a little cheaper good service will order again

This was very poor indeed, the wind up mechanism did not work at all. I would not recommend.

The box was empty!