When Pencil Met Gel Sharpenable Longwear Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Blackest Black) High-Performance, Waterproof, Transfer & Smudge Proof Eyeliner

I have half a dozen of these now, they are easy to use, soft on the lid, draw smooth no snagging and last all day. They fix well, hold their colour and come off easily at the end of the day. I'm a 50 something woman with post menopausal skin, lines and a bit of drying around the eyes. The darker colours hold true for longer, the shimmer colours are lovely but do tend to fade after about 16hrs. The gold one tends to shed a bit but its a nice look and you can layer the shimmer colours over the darker ones after setting time, which gives it a nice look which lasts! A bit pricey for what they are but comparable to other brands. If you work in a hot busy environment like me - ward based - they are worth a go. They come singly, no sharper included, that's extra and IS pricey for what it is.

I don't often buy eye pencils as they drag on skin and then disappears when my eyes water, as I seem to react to lots of make up. But this feels quality, more like a very soft crayon, not waxy but glides on so soft can barely feel it and is not sticky. Colour looks gorgeous but not glittery and best of all it stays on all day even if my eyes water, but comes off easily with elemis make up remover. Highly recommend, especially if you're on wrong side of fifty and nothing stays!

I was pleased with this pencil in that it was easy to apply and did stay put, so no more panda eyes. Problem is that because it's so soft it needs sharpening after every couple of applications and it's not that easy to sharpen. the first time the lead came off completely. To give it benefit of the doubt I've bought a new, supposedly top quality sharpener but I'm not sure how long it will last if I've got to sharpen it every other day it could work out expensive.

Lovely colour and super smooth application. But definitely not waterproof and definitely not smudge proof.

I have been using this pencil in Smoky Plum for a few years now, love the colour, glides over the eye area without pulling, good price, I have slightly oily skin around the eyes so use a little concealer just to secure the colour stays put, but on normal skin your probably fine.

Worst eyeliner I’ve ever used. It smudges, gets cakey so quickly that my entire eye area ends up looking black. The ads are a complete lie

First I thought I love it . Nice shiny colour much cheaper than Beckham . then , every time I wear it , it doesn’t stay and particles go into my eyes and eyes turn red and painful .

I am very impressed with this eye liner pencil. I wasn't sure to try at first because I hadn't heard of the brand so I did a little research and decided to try it. So pleased I did!. I have no complaints, it's very soft and workable. The colour brown is lovely and the most important thing for me it doesn't make my eyes water. This is a problem with some brands with me. So it's a yes from me! I will definitely buy again. Now I have been introduced to the brand I wouldn't hesitate to purchase other lines from this brand.

This product is great for for the fine skin of a certain age. It glides on easily, and while it does smudge a bit, it lasts pretty much the entire day. The soft black is more like a charcoal color which doesn't look as severe as some of the black liners, and it maintains a fine line for several applications before requiring sharpening. Nice product.

I have been searching for a replacement for the Benefit Eye Bright (which they stopped making over a year ago). It was the perfect pink color. I've tried LOTS of different pencils trying to find the right shade but not had any luck, until I found this pencil! It is the perfect pink color (not too brown, not to white), and it goes on really smooth. I would highly recommend it!

After years of buying countless different eyeliners....this is the only one that works! Goes on smoothly.... Color is beautiful.... Lasts all day. Congrats on a great product! I'm hooked...

I purchased the set of 4 pencils. These pencils are easy to use and glides on smoothly. Each pencil is packaged in an individual little box and came in excellent condition. I wish there was the option to choose your own colours though. Will definitely be ordering the navy smoke.

The color is vibrant! Goes on easily and stays on! Beautiful teal color!