Cloud Star Tricky Trainers Soft & Chewy Dog Treats, Liver, 14 oz. Pouch

I had originally bought this product back in 2022-2023 and i'd be lying if i said the quality has gone down. I saw a review saying they changed the formula and the texture was off but unless my other bag was just stale, these feel super similar, softer if anything! They cut super easily, they have never given my dog a stomach ache+ She absolutely loves them! Some complain about the smell but i prefer it, it helps my dog focus on training and the smell left on your hands goes away after 2-3 washes so it's not a big deal. The one thing i do wish they had was an option to buy in bulk for a slightly cheaper price haha. Or just a larger size bag because it feels like i'm going through so much so quickly since i'm currently training my dog haha Overall super good quality, they last a while, they're not super expensive and they look like kibble so its easy for me to mix her food in a ziplock bag with them so they get the smell! lmao

Small, soft treats for our shi tzu. She loves them!

Bella loves them. High value treats?

My Yorkie is in a constant state of training. She's nearly 6 years old but she loves to learn new things plus she loves snacks. She's picky though and shuns so many treats that I buy her. I decided to give these Cloud Star Tricky Trainers a try. They have good ingredients in them, are small and chewy, and are made in the USA. Molly likes them. At first she ignored them preferring her usual Dingo Training Treats. But when she realized she wasn't getting those, she gave these a try. And now she is a fan. The size is perfect for her because she is so little and she is a huge fan of chewy treats as opposed to biscuits and such. These are more expensive than Dingo and Zukes, both of which I have purchased a number of times, but they have better ingredients so I guess you get what you pay for. Although Molly eats these treats, she still does prefer Dingos. I gave her a choice and it was no contest. When I run out of Dingos, I won't replace them and my dog will forget all about the Dingos she loves. I think I will stick with these for the health of my dog. They are pricey though and I hope they don't get pricier!

My dog LOVES these. She is reactive, so we can't really take her on walks or anything, so the way we exercise her is by teaching and practicing tricks. Because these have a low calorie count, I don't worry about giving her too many. We also use them to stuff a kong toy or a snuffle mat and she cannot get enough. They are reasonably priced (we have it on subscribe and save because we use a lot of them) but it is a good size bag for the money. They have never made my dog sick, and she seems to digest them well. Definitely a great option for a little snack for the pup!