Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Deep Black Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof

At first, I honestly doubted the staying power of this eyeliner because it is incredibly soft — literally like butter. It glides on effortlessly and is super pigmented; one single stroke is enough to get a sharp, intense line. It blends very easily, and you actually have enough time to smudge it if you want to create a softer look. And then — the magic happens! Once it sets, it stays rock solid. I can rub it with my finger and it doesn’t move at all. No smudging, no transferring, no creasing — not even a hint. This is truly a luxurious, high-quality product. I’m seriously impressed and would absolutely recommend giving it a try!

I have tried every eyeliner out there! I have oily lids so I have only used liquid eyeliner. This eyeliner doesn't budge and lasts for 12 hours. Easy to apply. I was skeptical at first but now I have purchased 4 colors. I have brown eyes and the olive and violet look amazing.

Was pretty surprised with this eyeliner.. was easy to put on, glides very smooth. It's a little thicker than a liquid eyeliner but overall super impressed with the price point, the quality and the overall application of the product. The color is nice and lasted the night. Was also easy to get off with eye makeup remover.

Love this eyeliner. I really do. It lasts just like it says it does on eyes! Woke up the next morning looking almost exactly like when I put it on, with slightest of fading. Does not smudge easily at all! Only problem. I used it maybe 10 times total? And I dont apply the wings or anything excessive, just to top and bottom eyeline. And I am already out... for the price, I feel like there should be more. Update: I initially did try to sharped with an automatic makeup sharpener and it did NOT do anything. It was almost like it was not suppose to be sharpened. HOWEVER, I went out and bought a small simple makeup sharpener and it actually worked. Granted... It chips weird on sides of eyeliner pencil. Its a but rough, little jagged because of whatever material its made of. BUT it worked and I have more now!! So disreguard first comment!

For once I actually found an eyeliner that does what it says it will. I particularly have issues with liners staying on my waterline but 5 hours later and it's clinging strong with no smudging. It goes on easily and silky smooth. Obviously it's waterproof! I'd say it's definitely worth the $18. I got it in black and it's very saturated.

The product itself is nice. It is creamy and goes on well. It lasts all day too. The problem I have is that it melts down very fast and you will need to sharpen it every use. That brings up another issue. The pencil is terrible. It doesn't sharpen well. It splints which makes it dangerous to use. I even bought a new sharpener but it's the same thing. Not worth the risk of using.

Wonderskin is seriously 50/50 for me. I've gotten a few products that are exactly how they seem, and then mostly they are awful somehow so I was reluctant to try this but I'm always looking for long wear smudge proof eyeliner b/c my eyes water like crazy. To be clear, my go to holy grail is Maybelline New York unstoppable eyeliner pencil the twist up one. I have it in almost every color and it is incredible, never smudging stays on forever. The only reason I'm not the biggest fan of it is that it doesn't always glide on how I want my eyeliner to. I saw this one glides on real well, and I thought maybe it was worth giving it a go despite my dislikes with this brand. I was wrong. It GLOBS on. Even when I refrigerate it so it's not too warm. It clumps all over my eyes and lashes. I used cotton swabs to try to fix it. It DOES smoke out real nicely, but it also smudges pretty bad. It stays where you put it, but it also gets everywhere. Especially if it's clumping. HERE'S THE WORST PART THO. while it did last all day long (I still had it mostly intact where I applied it through my 8 hour shift, after work drinks, making dinner, all night until I washed my face before bed), it also started flaking really badly in hard chunks after my work day. I was constantly getting big hard flakes on my eyeball and it hurt. It was coming off in hard chunks and leaving bare spots where it lifted. I haven't had something like that happen since I was in middle school in 1998 and bought the worst quality liquid liner you could ever imagine at a dollar store because that's all I could afford. So that's my closest comparison, decades old memories of horrible dollar store makeup. I'm not about this and I don't think it's worth trying even if it's on sale.

I’ve been using this eyeliner regularly and love how deep and rich the black color is. It glides on smoothly without tugging and gives a clean, precise line. Once set, it stays put most of the day with minimal smudging, even around the waterline. The pencil sharpens well and doesn’t crumble. Great option for everyday wear or a more defined look.