BLK/OPL Smudge-Proof Eyeliner Pencil, Precision Eye Definer - Highly-Pigmented Waterproof Eye Liner Pencils - Moisturizing & Creamy Smooth Application-Vegan Makeup Safe for Sensitive Eyes-After Hours

This eye liner is great, do not smudge. Great color and i got compliments when I used it. I got another one in case they discontinued as it is difficult to find a good eye liner that last.

Love it!

So smooth and creamy!

I really like the tip and that's all I got, the first tip. I did not get anymore than that. The instructions state to twist the bottom. I did that and got nothing more. I tried the makeup pencil sharpener and it was worse If you want to pay $8 for less than an inch of eyeliner which is all you going to get - your choice. A big disappointment. Gonna search for another one

I like how it's waterproof but I can't get any more product out of the pencil. The twist bottom doesn't work so I can't use the whole pencil.

I adore the color & how smooth it glides on. I’ve seen NONE that comes close to this product

nice but i can’t sharpen it! i have to find a pencil sharpener that it fits in!

Excellent