Polkadog Cod Skins for Dogs (4.7oz Regular) - Single Ingredient, Wild-Caught Fish Skin Dog Treats for All Breeds – High in Lean Protein & Omega-3. Hypoallergenic, Grain Free. Handcrafted & Made in USA

Perfect natural snack

My dog loves them. I was worried spending so much money on them not knowing if my dog would like it. When it arrived, the bag was huge! So it may seem like a lot of money, but this is not a small bag of treats. It is a great value for such a pure and healthy snack. It is very crunchy and will crumble and make somewhat of a mess, but my dog licks it all up. I don't even need the vacuum cleaner. It smells a little fishy, but I don't find it offensive. My dogs breath doesn't smell horrible afterwards. It's like a clean fish smell and then it goes away rather quickly. It doesn't bother me. His bully sticks are another issue. They smell much worse and smell long afterwards! I feel really good about giving him these treats. My dog isn't on a gluten free diet, but I try to limit his gluten intake so as not to overburden his system, and he likes variety. This is a great option. I understand these snacks are also good for dogs who have problems with certain proteins. I had a dog once that could not eat chicken or beef protein and had to have very special food. These would have probably been a great treat for him if he was alive today.

It's not my thing, but my two young Labrador retrievers love these cod skins. I have my two young dogs share one by snapping a rod in half, but occasionally they will get a whole stick. I usually buy Beams by Holistic Kitchen, but wanted to give these a try. These a very long and thin compared to shorter but wider beams. The are similar in price*, smell, and likely taste (just assuming!). They consume in about same amount of time, too.*For me, Beams are similar in price when I buy them at a local pet store, they are more expensive on Amazon, making this product the better by in terms of price.The product so far seems pretty great, and I may look into buying their larger 2lb bag. Such a healthy treat!I've yet to offer any to my cats. They aren't big on treats. However, one of my cats eats primarily wet food and gets a bit picky at time. I imagine if I pulverized a piece of it and sprinkled it onto their food that that may pique their interest.

Nice and stinky fish for my dog that I have to focus one protein for. I recommend ensuring your dog is in an area where you don't mind getting messy so I like letting them go outside with this as it gets crunchy all over the place. But the dogs love it and we'll lick it up if it's a hard surface.

Our hound dog is allergic to everything. With these cod skins or the one thing that he can eat day and night without any issues at all. They smell awful.... because they're dead fish of course, lol and they're very messy, but they are hysterical to listen to them crunch through these crazy super crunchy dead fish skins. They also cleaned my hounds teeth! Free bonus! We subscribe to these now

I want to start this off by saying that these are some of my dog’s favorite treats. It’s exactly what it’s marketed as. Single ingredient cod skin rolls. I’m really happy with these treats and I’m relieved that my dog is able to enjoy them without getting an upset stomach.However, these are incredibly inconsistent. I don’t mind because I break them up anyways, but keep it in mind when looking at the money aspect. The sizes are all over the place. I bought the 2.5 oz regular sized ones. You can see the difference in sizes in the picture. These are all the treats that came in this tube. For a large dog, this isn’t enough and probably not worth it unless you buy the gigantic bag one. For a small dog, it works perfect.My dog is 11lbs and gets maybe 2-3 a week. She has fish in her food already so I try to limit it in treats. I break all the pieces up so they’re about the size of the bottom two sticks. They lasted since Christmas. This is my second time purchasing. The first one I bought had more in it though so we’ll see.They are crunchy so not for dogs with chewing issues. They don’t last long as a chew for bite-y dogs. It takes mine maybe 2 minutes, but my girl also devours these as quickly as possible. Because of how much she enjoys them, I don’t have a problem with buying this. Maybe in the future I’ll get a bigger sized version, but it’s a pretty big jump from 3 oz to 32.Case in point, these are high value rewards made with one ingredient. They are crunchy but still retain fish oil that gives them an extra shine. They smell like fish (because they are) but it doesn’t linger afterwards and I don’t mind personally. The sizing is too inconsistent but I don’t think these treats are expensive for such a high quality product. They are obviously hand rolled because no two treats are the same. While I would be a lot more happier if every batch was made the same as the first time I bought this, I can’t deny my dog’s obvious enthusiasm for these.

My dog loves them always drinks water afterwards. The container is brittle I usually put them in treat jar when they get home

My Boston Terrier goes nuts for these - which is great, but the real benefit is her stool is always consistent and on time with these. I have done a few experiments and 100% these are the reason for my somewhat finicky girl's stomach and digestion are now perfect. Thanks yall.