PetSafe Spray Refill - Citronella - No-Mess Replacement Cartridges Spray Dog Bark Collar Remote Training Collar - Refill Cartridge Only - 3-Pack - PAC00-16371

I have a Silky Terrier who barks at everything. I have paid for trainers and tried a variety of bark control products and techniques but this is the only thing that works. I only put it on when he gets really bad. I love how it’s enough to distract him when he’s in the middle of his high pitch barking and I always make sure to reward with a treat when he stops. I wish you got more than three in a pack for the price. If you have an automatic collar and a stubborn dog like Bailey a cartridge might not last very long especially in the beginning. It should have more in a cartridge or a way to refill them with the cans. It also does have a strong citronella scent so at the end of the day when he uses it I tried to wipe him down a little bit. If you buy this product give it a chance to work but don’t expect amazing results because sometimes years later he still has to gets sprayed.

The 3 pack regularly goes on sale on Amazon, but even at full price, it is cheaper than what the pet stores charge. My dog hates the citronella smell and usually stops barking after just 1 spray. These are original brand and well made. They drop right into the collar and work as intended.

I have a Chihuahua and consequently there's plenty of barking at our house. We tried several bark collars but this was the only one that worked.The cartridges work great BUT not all cartridges are created equal. Most of them work for about 30 or so sprays, as advertised. A couple of them only worked for a few barks- maybe 8. I had one cartridge that lasted almost 6 days, which was very nice.Imo the cost should be about $10, not the current price.Despite the price I would recommend this cartridge and collar because they really work.

I have a Rottweiler who likes to lick the sliding glass door when he's outside. We have a problem of him licking the door instead of going potty. Or he taps the door and scratches the screen.Our trainer suggested we get this for him to stop the licking. It works great! The citronella makes him sneeze, but we only had to spray twice. Now all that's needed is a beep. It's a nice tool to use for training when you can't be physically by my dogs side.

We bought these and the collar for my dog when she barks unnecessarily (someone walking through the apartment hall). This has been the only thing to actually work with her! We tried the beeping collars, vibrating collars, and even the three setting ones that beep, vibrate, and then shock (was not our favorite). However, this collar is the only thing that will help her not bark for no reason and it’s not harmful. Highly recommend!

We purchased the petsafe spray collar for our pooch and it seemed to work really well, i read all the reviews about how the spray would run out quickly, so i decided to purchase one extra pack to have on hand. We barely use the collar throughout the day so i assumed it would last us a decent amount of time before running out. The one that came with the collar lasted us about 4 days, so i opened up this pack and replaced the cartridge ready to not worry for another couple of days. NOPE! After just one day of use it was already flashing yellow saying that it was low. Whats even more annoying is the fact that our dog barely even barked/howled that day that we used it, so by far it should have sprayed way less than usual, so it is rediculous that it ran out just after 1 day of use. Sadly this is the only product that actually works on our dog that doesnt hurt him, so we are stuck. If you want to use this, be aware, you’ll need to purchase a couple of extra packs just to get you through the week. Hopefully he curbs his barking habit quick or we’ll be pinching pennies from how many cartridges we have to buy

Once I got it on right side up it worked great. My 9 lb. Pomeranian has anxiety issues and barks at anyone near him. The spray is not a bad smell at all. Didn’t last long in the beginning but as he stopped barking so much we didn’t need to use the collar as often. Just hold it up and he would not bark. I highly recommend this for any dog that continually barks and it is safe as well. I suggest getting the refills when purchasing the collar so you don’t run out unexpectedly like we did. My dog is small so I had to shorten the collar to fit snug no problem. Hope this helps it saved our sanity and now we can bring him everywhere with us.

My dog is a barker, I have to accept that. I’ve spent SO much money on products to try and get him to stop. My neighbor is so annoyed they put up a privacy fence. Needless to say, this does not work on my stupid dog.