Sigma BeautyMATTE liquid Pen EyeLiner, smooth vegan formula, Comfortable long-lasting wear, water & smudge-proof makeup, Black Wicked.

If you don't have oily eyelids - go for it!

No me gustó el producto, después de 6 días de uso se secó, no lo recomiendo y no lo volvería a comprar, ya no lo pude devolver pero muy malo, estoy muy decepcionada!

Added the picture to illustrate the issue. The tip is still in tact and it doesn’t look like it’s dried, but it didn’t take long (two uses) before it stopped producing solid lines. Trying to go over a line that didn’t pick up very well (ie didn’t create a solid line) just makes the issue worse, picks up and removes more of the product so you get more patchiness in your liner. Also, even when it was creating solid lines (first two uses) they weren’t clean because it bleeds (second image illustrates this)Overall, not impressed at all, I saw this on a YouTube review of about 30 different liquid and felt liners. It didn’t get a good review but we seemed to be looking for different things so I thought it might have just been her personal preference because her swatches of it looked good but it definitely doesn’t pick up well, last long, smudges a lot and bleeds.

I've never actually been able to wear eyeliners as they all give me a reaction. Swollen eyes, redness, and gross goop when I wake up despite taking it off before bed, the sight is.... unpleasant.I've always bought low-end liners, and thought I would try this high-end one as a last resort before officially giving up.All I can say is it's absolutely perfect, in all ways. I've got a grand total of 0 negatives about the product.It's super easy to put on - small or thick lines. It's black, and when I say black I mean a proper deep gorgeous black. The flow is even, not dry and patchy, or super heavy and liquidy coming out.One of the best things for me is taking it off. Most liners turn liquid and run down my face when I take them off, but this one comes off almost like a dry erase marker if that makes sense? Very minimal raccoon eyes and no allergic reactions at all!!!I honestly don't know why it doesn't have higher reviews, I'm seriously head over heels for this stuff. Definitely my ride or die eyeliner.

I was previously using a liquid+brush liner from Maybelline that would dry up and chip. I'd be 6 hours into the day and have a ridiculous looking gap above my eye.I like this pen. I'm not a beauty guru, I just needed an easy, dark liquid liner that stayed and this stuff stays on all day for me. You sometimes have to go over it once again because it gets a little thin, but you can get a jet black from it, and it's easy enough to use for thin lines or thick ones. When it comes off, it fades rather than chips away leaving you looking like a clown. I haven't had the drying or clumping issues others have (but I don't have oily skin), and the tip doesn't fray drastically but occasionally gets these little hairs at the end and you just snip them off.

Saw this reviewed on a YouTube video, and indeed it looked very black, exactly what I wanted. Got it, used it only a few times, but the tip has started to fray leaving little hairline 'snaggle' threads of liner along my cats-eye look. I tried to fix that by increasing the pressure as I applied it but that only thickened the line and the snaggle-threads also got wider. I ended up with Amy Winehouse-thick cats-eye, which is fine, but not the look I was going for.Wanted to love this product, and I do love the inky blackness; maybe I just got a bad one? Not sure I'd buy it again with so many options out there.Beware YouTube 'influencer' videos with young makeup gurus; they can make anything look good for the one-time they try it, but they rarely take the time to truly test a product over time.