Beauty Spot (12pcs) Nabi Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Long Lasting Fade Resistant Formula - Quick Makeup Remover (White)

You get what you pay for- they work. Very light and oily abd don't last long- I'm giving it 5 stars due to price, description & shipping. If you're like me- I NEED SOME EYELINER - good if you aren't in the sun or need it to be long wearing. Honestly if you have a dollar store, you're a bit better off- BUT I knew what I was buying

I noticed no eye irritation while using this. It stays on, is pretty pigmented, and I've noticed it is pretty waterproof. It can all be removed with a bit of makeup remover. My only complaint is that it is pretty flimsy, and I've had a couple break, but I feel that should be expected for this kind of eyeliner. Perfect for eyes and contour!

Price and ease to use.

These liners go on smoothly and the black is very black. As far as smudging, because everyone's skin and skin produced, my situation may be different than other people. When I first used it, the under eye (not water line) did smudge a lot. However I started using setting powder before applying and fitted more on after putting on liner and smudging problems resolved. For the price and getting a lot, I don't think I will need to buy eyeliner for years!!!

Eyeliners were easy to use, well made, received quickly, covers well and provides a fine colorful line, smudge resistant, reasonable pricing...would reorder. :)

Great for injector - facial markings

The color doesn’t come out at all. At first I thought it was just one of them but no, it’s all of them. I even tried to heat it slightly to draw the color out. Do not buy these eyeliners. They’re horrible.

Very soft application, easy on, stays on & blends well. Best I’ve found in a while.