Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Clean Mascara + Lash Primer | Lengthening + Volumizing | Cruelty Free + Safe for Sensitive Eyes | Black, .27 fl oz

This gives real length without clumps, flakes, or irritation. The primer adds just enough grip, and the mascara builds without turning crunchy. I’ve got sensitive eyes, and it doesn’t bother them at all. Clean, simple, and actually makes my lashes look better and fuller, not overdone or cakey.

This is my new favorite mascara! It makes my eyelashes extremely long without clumping. I get nervous that clean mascara are too oily and will leave my eyes looking too black- but that was not the case with this one. This is a great product.

I really like this mascara. I was using mascara which was not labeled as using clean ingredients. I switched to this one and after a few weeks, I noticed my eyelashes were longer, fuller, and healthier. The only problems I have had is it clumping my eyelashes quite a bit and it flaking throughout the day, adding to my permanent dark circles under my eyes. A lash comb fixes the clumping pretty easily and I have just learned to wipe under my eyes throughout the day to get the flakes off. Knowing the product I'm using is clean and safer than others is worth those two small inconveniences.

I've been slowly trying to switch over to clean, nontoxic products more recently and have found that Honest Beauty has been my go-to for makeup products.First of all, I'm a big fan of the fact that this mascara has both the primer and the actual mascara in one bottle.The wands are slim wands, so it causes more clumping, but this is still something that I can work with.It will take a bit more practice from me tho, as the mascara dries much faster than what I am used to, so multiple applications might clump a bit more in the beginning. I'm not going to take stars off of the product for this one because I know the formula is different being a clean product and I still wasn't upset with how it looked first using it. I'll get better at it with time.I had no sensitivity or irritation in my eyes at all, neither while applying or while removing.Removal was extremely easy and didn't make me feel I had to fight to get it off.Overall this is a mascara I will be sticking with and am pleased with my experience

Three stars for clean formula. Otherwise not good. I bought this mascara despite the negative reviews because I value clean ingredients. Unfortunately, it has quite a few issues. The brushes are inconvenient and make it hard to comb through the lashes properly. The formula is too thick, making it easy to apply too much, and it dries quickly, causing clumps. I bought an additional lash comb, which helped a little, but the result still doesn’t look great.

TL;DR: For over $21, you better fill both sides of the tube. No primer = no business from me.I used this product for over a year and I enjoyed the quality of the eye makeup experience. Yes, it cost more, but I appreciated the "good values" and believed that I had chosen a company that I could trust. I was wrong.For context, I replace my mascara about every three months to help with eye health. However, each time I have reordered this product there has been less mascara and less and LESS primer. The most recent time I ordered it, the primer essentially came empty!!!!!!! So, for the last three months, I put on my mascara each day and I was unable to use the primer. This has made me so angry. Putting on my eye makeup is such a nice, daily routine to feel pretty in the morning and it just sucks because I THOUGHT I chose a company that was supposed to be better than screwing over their customers.My three months are up and I am switching back to my Maybelline because it delivers the same eye makeup result for a fraction of the cost and they have always provided me enough product. I switched from Maybelline to Honest Beauty for all the "right reasons," but Honest Beauty's lack of honesty has lost my business.

Best one so far. I always suffer from the mascaras irritating my eyes and leaving dark tint around my eyes. But this right here has been a game changer. Feels great, no irritation, no glups, no tint,.... just super great look and safe for my eyes.

I wasn’t sure if I was going to like this mascara, but this was such a win! I’m used to using 100% pure mascara ( another low tox mascara) I absolutely prefer the honest one better! It’s super dark and doesn’t get clumpy at all. The primer and mascara lasted me over a month I use it daily! Easy to remove!