Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks for Small Dogs 5-6" (10 Count) - Long Lasting for Light Chewers and Puppies - Natural Beef Dog Chew Bones

Why did you pick this product vs others?:Papillon loves this. Chews for 30 minutes. They have a low odor, but nothing terrible. I ordered small 6 pk. But now ordered larger ones. Dod chews forever on these. Ok not actually, but he chews the larger bully sticks for hours at a time. He'll leave it and come back to it again and again. Its on reorder!

Excellent for small dogs or puppies that are not hard but not too soft that tastes good to them. Healthy ingredients and do not break easily. Great for a training reward at the end of each session.

My dachshund & chihuahua are both obsessed. These have helped a bit with the tartar build up on one’s teeth, & have been great for teething for my puppy. They soften as they chew so I don’t worry about hard pieces being swallowed or choked on. My smaller dogs are able to chew one of these down in a day. My only complaint is that with this larger bag, it’s only about double the amount of the smaller ten dollar bag because the sticks are much thicker in this bag than the small bag.

These are great for my Husky puppy. He seems to like them, and they keep him from chewing on everything else for about an hour! However, on a selfish note… the smell is horrendous! I can’t give one to my puppy when I’m home. The smell makes me gag, and it sticks to his breath for hours. With that, unfortunately I won’t buy the product again… but that’s just due to my own problems lol… my husband says that the smell doesn’t really bother him. I normally give one to my puppy when I leave the house for errands, and it keeps him busy while I’m gone. So that’s the important plus!!

My dog loves this treat. The size is perfect for him and the ingredients have never caused any issues.

My little BABYGIRL, Beagle/JR Terrier mix, 6 years old (adopted at 4 weeks of age). absolutely loves these. In fact she won’t chew/eat any other kind. I love the fact that they only have ONE ingredient “Beef Pizzle” sourced from free range cattle not fed antibiotics and definitely not Rawhide, no preservatives, no dyes, no added xtra’s just pure Beef Pizzle. They have a very distinct smell which most people don’t like. In fact if these bully sticks don’t have that distinct smell, she won’t touch them and she has to have the xtra thin. Bought some larger ones but she didn’t like, she only hid them. The xtra thin she chews like crazy. She’ll have one eaten in about 15 min. so i usually give her 2 since they are so small, smaller than the size of a pencil. They are very digestible and of course I watch her too. I’ve been feeding her these for several years. The quality has changed dramatically !! As you can tell from the photos they are very distorted. The edges are frayed and sharp spikes and big knots. I’ve had to throw away over half of them because I was afraid she would choke. I’ve bought over 16 bags in the past 6 months and each bag gets a little worse. If the seller happens to see this review I hope they will send me a good bag, like they’re supposed to be, thin and relatively smooth, not all distorted. I will probably still buy them since she loves them so much. I’ll just have to go thru bag and pick out the ones she can chew which usually is just 3 or 4. A waste of money I know but she’s my baby and she loves them so much.

My pups love this stuff. I feel much better about giving them this rather than rawhide, and for my little guy takes him a while to finish. The bigger golden just swallows most stuff without much chewing involved. Good value for the money and they like it.

Its more money for less bullystick. Shrinkflation is killing the value of this product, and this brand is making it very difficult for you to comparison shop with what you bought last time. But I did the math and here it is: I bought a bag of 50, six-inch bully sticks about two months ago. The bag was full of 5 inch sticks that were on the thin side ( see the pictures ). This was a 50 bag that weighed 37 ounces (sticker minimum net weight making each stick weigh 1.351 ounces ) So I said whatever and figured this was the new normal.Now I need another one. The 50 bag is no longer available so I’m buying a bag of 15, six-inch sticks. Irrespective of a lost bulk quantity discount, I am paying 26% more per ounce of bullystick for this bag than the last one. The price only went up from $3.10 per stick to 3.17 per stick, but these sticks are only 1.01 ounces. That is only 74% of the previous weight of 1.351 ounces per stick two months ago. I felt like I got ripped off when the 50 bag came, and now I’m getting ripped off again. The price essentially went up around 65% for me across both of these orders. It is my contention that this brand intentionally obfuscates increased prices over less quantity by not publishing a price per unit, varying availability of bulk orders and labeling their weights and measurements using pounds, ounces, grams, kilograms and fractions thereof interchangeably across product types and instances of the same product across time.Unfortunately, none of this is illegal as they still fall inside the bounds of the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act of 1967. But this is definitely not nice. They will continue to use their fun house mirror tricks on these products to continue selling you less bully stick for more money. This is so unfair to my doggies. Steve and Jay used to make a really solid product for a good value, and they still have the best bully stick on amazon, but the shrinkflation exposure we are getting here is painful.