4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara Black, Tubing Mascara Waterproof, Longer & Thicker Lashes, Voluminous Eyelashes, Clump-Free, Long-Lasting, Natural Smudge-Proof, Adds Length, Depth and Glamour Effortlessly

I’ve tried so many mascaras and this one looked promising so I ordered it. I’ve been using it with a primer and my lashes, which normally end up looking clumpy due to the clumpy mascaras or non-existent with others unless I layer it on, have looked fantastic.I hope it doesn’t dry out too quickly like some of the other brands because I’m really loving it right now and would love to stop looking for my number one brand for mascara.Crossing my fingers it stays a 5 star product for me. :)

Goes on nicely and stays on better than more expensive tubing mascaras like Blinc. Good sub for discontinued Charming Cat. After trying dozens of types, will stick with this.

Not waterproof. Sticky & stringy. Did not dry very fast.

This is a light on the lashes mascara. I'veused other tube mascara, but they were heavy and thick. It still makes my lashes look good and comes off easily. It also survived tears, but washes off with water. As a added bonus the tube is beautiful!

This stuff is terrible and I would never buy it again. It flakes and goes into your eyes so easily. It's also NOT a tubing mascara as they state! Buyer beware.

I like the product. The packaging is so cute.

I did not like this mascara for myself. It's very stringy when I pulled the wand out of the tube, and I didn't notice any significant difference in length, thickness or volume compared to my natural lashes. I ended up not using it long term and went back to my previous mascara.

This is the messiest mascara I have ever used. I thought tubing mascara would be better, but it is flaky, clumpy, and smears like crazy- not at all waterproof or stay-put whatsoever. I've bought higher quality mascara from dollar stores. The packaging is pretty, but the product is useless.