BUTTONED DOWN Men's Classic Fit Button-Collar Non-Iron Dress Shirt, Blue Gingham, 17.5" Neck 38" Sleeve

Nice shirt in terms of quality of materials. However it was too small by a lot. Even the "Classic Fit" has an annoyingly trim cut to it. Order a MUCH larger size. I ended up giving this one to my much slimmer teen aged son and it fit him well.

The shirt material is great as well as the fit, except for the length. I am 6'2 and wear a 36in sleeve, yet the shirt barely went lower than my waist and would not stay tucked in. Would be great if they offered true tall cut shirts, instead of just the sleeve length!

I know everyone is different, but I am so confused about negative reviews for Buttoned Down shirts. I am 6'6", weigh 265, and have a decent amount of muscle. I ordered a 17-1/2-38 classic fit shirt and it is great! The material is good quality, the fit is as good as you can expect for not being bespoke, the finish is good, and the are comfortable. I now own four and don't plan on buying any other shirt unless they stop selling them!

These shirts are fantastic quality. Beautiful fit and finish. I was previously buying Tommy Hilfiger dress shirts for my husband, who is a physician. He liked those in particular because they have a non-iron fabric that was easy to keep nice during the day. They also had a pocket for the pen light, pen, and other instruments he keeps on him. But, I noticed a decline in quality and started looking around. Buttons were coming off really quickly and that is just too annoying to deal with. They were also breaking on the second or third dry-cleaning. Why?!!! I saw these amazon shirts and thought I would give them a shot. They are much better quality and actually fit him better than the L-XL type sizing of Tommy Hilfiger. I could tell he felt more confident in these shirts. The patterns look more professional too. I hope Amazon doesn't get cheap on the manufacturing because I really like these.

Here's the situation - I have a large neck. Ordering for my neck size and sleeve length (20.5x35) you end up with the inside cut of the sleeve to be halfway down the chest. The shirt ends up looking like a wing suit! I've ordered these in blue, white and gingham. Only the white had a proper fit in the "classic" style. The other two are getting returned. I'm not a small guy but these seem to be cut for someone who is rotund. Perhaps I should have ordered slim fit. But I'm not certain. I think I'll just switch to MTailor or some other shirt maker. These are well-made and the material is fantastic. They just can't seem to get the fit right.

The material is nice and the quality was as I expected for the price. Unfortunately the length of the shirts is quite short - particularly in the tail length. I offered a 36" sleeve which is almost always good for me when buying other brands like Van Heusen or Joseph A Banks but these are at least two inches too short at the waist. I'd have to order at least a 38 but fear that the sleeve would be way too long.

Love the look, material, and quality of this shirt. BUT... It is a tad on the small size. Both neck and sleeves are small. I'm going to have to return this one mainly because the sleeves are a bit too short. Unfortunately, in the color I want, they don't have a 16 1/2 X 35" size.

Very strange fit after first wash and dry on mild heat. I ordered the next size up. I normally take a 17.5 with 35 inch sleeve and ordered 18/36 based on feedback from other buyers. Shirt fit a little big out of the package which I expected. After washing the sleeves were fine but the length in front/back shrank considerably as did shoulders. This shirt shrinks a lot even drying on mild heat. I rarely wash shirts after the first time, most are pressed at the cleaners so overall shrinkage is controlled. I will be asking to send this one back.