Cloud Star Tricky Trainers Crunchy Dog Training Treats 12 oz. Bag, Cheddar Flavor, Low-Calorie Behavior Aid with 680 Treats

I started buying these after my senior dog had an episode of pancreatitis and had to be switched to a low fat diet. I needed something that ranked as high as cheese but without that fat. These are very small which is excellent for repeat training. They have a strong cheese scent and even taste a lot like cheddar without the salt. Yes, I have tasted one. Yes I'm a crazy dog lady. Both of my current dogs love them will do just about anything I ask for one. They are very low fat and do not seem to trigger any tummy upset or allergy reactions in any of the dogs I have given them to. The caveat on that is that they are very small and I don't usually give more than 3 or 4 in one day. Be aware that if you order these with heavy items, they will likely be smashed to crumbs by the time they arrive. I try to ensure I only reorder with items that won't crush them.

Perfect for training! Smells like cheese & my dogs love them! Small and easy to carry in treat pouch or pocket. Crunchy A lot of treats per bag, great value for money!

These treats turned out to be a hit! My dog enjoys the crunch and eats them right out of my hand with no hesitation. I love that they’re only 2 kcals each, which makes them perfect for training or frequent rewards without worrying about overfeeding. The size and hardness also work well for puzzle toys, and the overall quality feels solid. Great value for money and definitely worth keeping on hand.

She seems to like this "okay." I swear it smells like Cheetos to me. There's no stomach upset at all, and this is good value, but I didn't notice the Canola oil until after I bought it; Next time I will purchase a brand without it. We don't need these man made oils when there are natural ones that are good for us.

My dog loved them but a bit pricey

We regularly buy these for everyday use for our two dogs. They are small enough that they can be given as training treats and we regularly use them on walks because we have a reactive dog that is very food motivated. We find these help to distract them from high stress situations and they absolutely love them. Whenever we bring these treats out they automatically sit and wait patiently for their treats. We've been able to teach our dogs many new tricks using these tasty treats. They are cheesy flavored with a cracker consistency so they don't harden over time like softer treats.

My dogs go nuts over the liver kind(purple bag). Even my unruly hyper 2 year old comes. The chewy ones are the best with stronger scent, plus they’re small so you don’t feel like you’re giving too much and they last longer amount wise. Good ingredients too. Worth the cost!

These are great, our Corgi loves these treats and does anything for them! Since they are low calorie you don’t have to worry about over feeding. It’s a great treat to train with