SHANY Cosmetics SHANY Gift Surprise- AMAZON EXCLUSIVE - All in One Makeup Bundle - COLORS & SELECTION VARY MULTI-COLORED, Unscented

The makeup box was awesome! I received a whole set up brushes that are high quality. The eye shadow colors in the palette were cute and vibrant. I also loved the eye and lip pencils which went on easily and didn't smear. I recommend this box. It was worth it!

Great quality and quantity of items with a good affordable price. The colors of eyeshadow are very diverse. Great for any look.

Great bundle! Love everything in it. Everything seems high quality and worth the money I will be ordering one to surprise my daughter.

10/10

I have order one box before. It was amazing. I bought 2 more just to see if they would be different. They were very different from the first one. But these 2 were very similar to each other. 6 things were different in each box then the other 8 things were the same. I'm still very happy with what I got though.

Cheaply made I was really disappointed because I have bought several of their other products and loves them all but this just didn’t do it for me it almost looked like little kids makeup. I returned it

I really like the items I received in my mystery box. The brushes alone are worth more than the whole bundle. There is a great variety of colors as well. I will prolly purchase again in the future.

My 2020 purchase had at least 2 times as many items as the 2024 box.From that standpoint, I have lowered my original rating from 5 stars (2020) to 3 stars (2024) because of the item quantity comparison. It could be that 2020 I had good luck and 2024 is more in line with what is “normal” so take that with a grain of salt.This box had the Glamor Girl makeup kit, a 14-piece rose gold brush set, the 12-piece mini lipgloss set, a lip pencil, a dual-ended eyeliner pencil, an eyeshadow pencil, a makeup sponge, a silver glitter nail polish, a set of pinkish false eyelashes and an eyelash curler.The items I remember from the 2020 box are the Shany Beauty Book, 14-piece rose gold brush set, 12-piece mini lip gloss set, 12-piece lip liner set, at LEAST 4-5 eyeshadow quads, Te Quiero 10-color eyeshadow palette, makeup sponge, black false eyelashes, eyelash curler, a sharpener plus multiple other items I have either used up by now or gave away because they weren’t my preference for colors.Positive notes:The makeup box had a coupon this year, and items were (still) packaged nicely. I did not experience damaged product like other people had mentioned, either in 2020 or 2024. Another perk is that I have experienced ZERO reactions to the makeup. I did have fun opening this box of random makeup.As far as the makeup itself, I am not a big makeup person so I cannot compare Shany to expensive brand names. The eyeshadows cover well and stays in place as far as I can tell, the brushes I still have haven’t fallen apart (some I threw because big rounded makeup brushes work great for chalk painting cabinets or smaller furniture!), and everything else works as expected.Overall, I am very happy with Shany as a brand and will be purchasing (other specific) Shany makeup sets as gifts for my nieces so I know exactly what is included. Truly, the only knock is my 2020 purchase was so good it made the 2024 one look less than stellar, when money-to-product wise the 2024 one was still worthwhile because of the coupon.