Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner: Long Lasting Color, Crease-proof, Waterproof, Gel-like Hydrating Formula, Perfect for Tightline, Lash Line + Waterline

The eyeliner is easy to apply and is a smooth gel. I found it a great find as I had ever purchased it before…but now I will again!

Just Fabulous!!!! Soft, goes on easy and is a beautiful brown. I’am going to order more💕

I have really sensitive skin, especially around my eyes and this product doesn't pull on your eyes or become itchy. If you need to make a correction dip a clean qtip or a pointy makeup type qtip in a bottle of non-oily makeup remover and fix your line. Wait about 30 seconds before you put on shadow. I think I've tried a dozen eyeliners and this is the Best one.

The pencil itself is a good color and stays on without irritation; however, attempting to sharpen is a huge problem. The pencil while sharpening, breaks off in the sharpener so 50% of the pencil has been wasted by the time you've finished using the eyeliner. I realize they make more money because you would have to keep repurchasing the pencil, but due to this significant flaw I will not buy it again.

The color is great and it stays on for hours! The cap doesn’t close with a snap sound. It just falls off in my bag. The pencil has gotten smooched , broken off, and needed more sharpening, which didn’t work well.

I love Laura Mercier everything and this is on the top of the list. Stays in place all day, even inside the lash line and doesn’t move to the inside corners of the eye ever ti make for that goopy black eye look. It also smudges great when first applied for a smoky look, but then doesn’t keep smudging throughout the day to places you don’t want it to. This is honestly the best eyeliner I have ever used and I have tried many. It is better than both Make Up Forever’s and NARS and those were the top of my list for quite some time. You will love this! I only wish I didn’t need to sharpen it as I do prefer that Make Up Forever’s waterproof long stay doesn’t need a sharpener.

Best eye liner pencil I’ve purchased in some time. And I have alot of makeup! Stays in place and very smooth going on the eye.

This formula is incredibly soft and finicky, and none of my cosmetic sharpeners can get a clean point without the pencil crumbling. For this price point, the pencil should come with its own compatible sharpener. After only a week of use, the product is essentially unusable. Extremely displeased with this purchase.